关于主机水冷和风冷哪个好

作者:中号硬核玩家

开箱

  对于绝大数DIY玩家来说,装机早已不是单单满足性能一方面了,而是主机整体视觉效果要得体和好看,从早期的RGB灯光开始赋予灵魂,再到各种品牌联名款,现今发展到硬件大厂都喜欢的全家桶模式,市场说明一切,玩家需求在随着时代而变化,这篇装机的核心主题就是RGB颜值和散热缺一不可。

  这次装机配件来自威刚旗下的XPG品牌最新推出的产品,它们分别是炫彩飓风风扇、霜盾炫彩水冷以及龙耀LANCER DDR5 6000内存,让RGB光污染照亮机箱每一个角落的同时,看看散热性能又如何吧。

  XPG最新推出霜盾炫彩360水冷,包装设计简洁大方——以产品渲染图+XPG家族代表的红色作为背景构成,左上方标注了ARGB灯效、低噪风扇、全铝冷排等产品卖点,同时注明是十二代酷睿的黄金搭配。

  霜盾炫彩360水冷定位主流级产品,外观设计是纯黑色的,主要由ARGB风扇和无限镜像水冷头构成,支持最新LGA 1700和AM4平台,按照官方给它的定位是可以压制Core i9、Core i7、锐龙R9和锐龙R7,后面我们会通过烤机测试一下,各大电商平台售价在500元左右,现在购买可享受两年的漏液险。

  三枚120mm ARGB冷排风扇,采用Rifle轴承结构,具有良好的噪声和寿命表现,最高转速可达到1800 RPM10%,最大风量可达到80.3 CFM,看数据还不错。

  风扇线材采用了类似菊花链的设计,供电和灯光线材是分开的,只要把它们串联起来,汇总一起接上延长线就完成了

此外水冷提供了SATA供电的ARGB控制器,按键可实现灯光模式、速度和亮度三种形式调节

  无限镜像LED水冷头,不通电的时候是镜面状态,通电后会呈现深邃的XPG LOGO ARGB灯效,水泵转速最高2400 RPM10%,噪声相对来说好控制

  LGA 1700平台扣具,其中底板是单独配备的,压力螺丝是和LGA 1200通用的,因为这样的配件最大简化,会使得安装流程变得简单

  风扇套装是XPG炫彩飓风系列,有120mm和140mm两种规格,这次装箱计划是4*120mm+2*140mm的组合,包装也是令人眼前一亮的XPG家族色彩。

  XPG炫彩飓风系列风扇,120mm和140mm分别内置了20颗和26颗LED灯珠,支持四大主板灯光体系同步,具备扇叶和环形双重ARGB效果,都是采用主流的FDB液压轴承,双层扇叶的特别布局,增强气流同时风阻更小,是一款RGB颜值和性能兼顾的产品。

  风扇也采用水冷相同的菊花链线材设计,尤其在机箱多达九个风扇之多的情况下,可以方便统一管理使用

  内存是XPG龙耀LANCER RGB DDR5 6000 16GBX2,DDR5 6000对于目前锐龙7000和十三代酷睿来说都是很合适的频率,除釉白和酷黑版本以外,龙耀LANCER RGB DDR5还拥有华硕吹雪联名和RO姬联名款。

  手上这款是龙耀LANCER RGB DDR5釉白,釉白顾名思义就是内存散热片使用了大面积釉白烤瓷以及CNC切割工艺,加上自身采用简洁和规则的本体,视觉感受十分不错。

   内存顶部是不规则的导光层,中间区域是XPG LOGO,灯效不算浮夸又简洁,支持华硕、微星、技嘉和华擎四大主板ARGB同步。因为RGB导光层是齐平散热片,所以内存兼容性相当好,和大型双塔风冷都不会发生冲突。

  散热片上拥有几何线条设计,左上方和右下方各有DDR5和XPG LOGO标识,从这个角度看也能发现导光层存在,呈“X”字形状,增加了RGB视觉效果却不占用内存体积大小,非常巧妙的设计。

  另一侧面标注了内存时序和序列号信息,这套内存的时序是DDR5 6000 CL40-40-40,工作电压为1.35V,支持XMP 3.0配置文件,参数来说还是比较保守和主流的,不过它采用的是SK Hynix海力士的原厂DDR5颗粒,完全可以再发掘下潜力。

整机和点亮效果

  这次装配XPG散热套的机箱是微星MPG VELOX 刀锋100R白色款,外观属于典型的侧透机箱设计,前部预装三枚120mm ARGB风扇,内置六路ARGB控制器,前置I/O支持LED灯效切换、具备USB 3.2 Gen 2 Type-C接口,风道设计良好,这款机箱定位比较均衡,既可以展示RGB灯效也有一定散热性能。

  整机使用微星这款MPG A1000G全模组产品,采用全日系105电容,通过了80Plus金牌认证,支持RTX 4090这种发烧级显卡,尺寸只有150mm长,一些体积稍大的ITX机箱都可以兼容到位,拥有十年质保售后。

  机箱前部是XPG炫彩飓风140mm*2+120mm*1组合,对于这款机箱,风扇适合外装,能够充分展示RGB效果,其次140mm规格靠上安装,毕竟主要为核心硬件服务,最低下安装120mm就足够了,因为对应服务的是硬盘。

  侧面还安装了两个120mm规格风扇,安装采用进风使用的方式,因为这款机箱并不是偏性能向,个人希望这样做可以保证进风量,排风主要依靠360水冷和后者的120mm规格风扇

整机RGB灯效可以通过MSI Center这款软件进行控制,主板同步可用的灯效支持多达十一种

微星MPG VELOX 刀锋100R机箱+XPG炫彩飓风RGB效果

XPG炫彩飓风风扇RGB细节特写,双层RGB设计足够炫彩,亮度也更亮

机箱内部RGB展示,可以看到风扇反装后视觉效果也是一样的

XPG霜盾炫彩360水冷头RGB效果,很深邃也有立体感

XPG龙耀LANCER RGB DDR5 6000内存RGB灯效,视觉效果相当简洁和柔和

侧面的XPG炫彩飓风风扇

后置的XPG炫彩飓风风扇

上机测试

  CPU-Z和GPU-Z一览,散热性能测试的核心对象是Intel Core i7-12700KF处理器和RTX 3070显卡,主板是微星MPG Z690 CARBON WIFI DDR5暗黑,足够具有代表性和参考性,搭载Windows 11 21H2最新系统,最新版本NVIDIA驱动522.25WHQL,全程封箱测试,室温大概27。

  AIDA64内存和缓存测试,DDR4 4800 C40 GEAR2,读取速度为73300MB/s,写入速度为67761MB/s,复制速度为66651MB/s,延迟为87.5ns,默认配置下延迟略高,但是由于DDR5起步就是4800MHz,读写性能是跨时代的,即便是DDR4高频内存也是望尘莫及。

  开启XMP 3.0配置后,内存顺利超至6000MHz CL40-40-40-76并成功一次点亮开机,读取、写入和复制速度都有质一般的飞跃,其内存延迟也从87.5ns降低到77.4ns,这时候相比主流的DDR4 3600已经有了翻倍级的读写性能提升。

  当然,如果对XMP超频表现不满意,也可以自行超频,经过简单调试,手上这款龙耀LANCER RGB DDR5 6000可以顺利超到DDR5 6400MHz,并且时序调整为32-38-38-74,内存电压加至1.45V,VDD和VDDQ电压稍微加一点点,此时读取性能已经快接近100000 MB/s了,同时延迟降至66.1ns,延迟表现基本可以持平DDR4 3600 Gear 1模式,这个超频结果可以顺利通过RunMemtest Pro 5.0 100%烤机测试,可在日常稳定使用。

  CPU散热测试使用AIDA64 FPU烤机项目,为了加大强度,这里还把i7-12700KF的性能核心超频至5.0GHz,而能效核心默认保存不变,固定核心电压1.22V,烤机15分钟后,XPG霜盾炫彩360冷排风扇并未完全满载,CPU Package最高温度为87,此时软件读取CPU功耗为200W,各个性能核心没有超过90,能效核心统一稳定73,散热表现良好。

  显卡散热测试使用3DMark Time Spy,二十轮满载测试下来,对于RTX 3070这款中高端显卡,可以达成98.5%稳定度通过,频率发挥也正常,机箱前面和侧面区域明显感觉是有吸入冷风,组建风道良好。

总结

  威刚XPG这些产品使用下来不错吧,双环RGB风扇在视觉效果不错之余,对于机箱进风和排风都能起到至关作用,而XPG霜盾炫彩360水冷确实如宣传所说,压制i7级别的处理器是比较轻松的,尤其文中CPU还进行了超频操作,散热效果还是不错,最后如果近期有购入新一代锐龙7000和十三代酷睿平台,也可以考虑下XPG龙耀LANCER RGB DDR5 6000这款内存,高频之余还有一定超频潜力。

","force_purephv":"0","gnid":"9d4f308e9b6c0e18a","goods_list":[{"goods_channel":"天猫精选","goods_cover":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t0124da9b3b6ee9fa13.jpg?size=600x600","goods_link":"https://go.smzdm.com/9e766832f749e823/ca_fz_0_0_0_0_0_0_0","goods_name":"威刚霜盾炫彩240/360一体式水冷CPU散热器ARGB风扇电脑主机箱冷排","goods_pos":1,"goods_price":"479"},{"goods_channel":"天猫精选","goods_cover":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t0142b19862548eb465.jpg?size=600x600","goods_link":"https://go.smzdm.com/9272ddd49c069e8f/ca_fz_0_0_0_0_0_0_0","goods_name":"威刚炫彩ARGB机箱风扇12/14CM温控风扇台式机电脑风冷散热器DIY","goods_pos":2,"goods_price":"89"}],"img_data":[{"flag":2,"img":[{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t012a4e54b64a3cde73.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t010fa3c565fecd7b8e.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t01ed19ed1f6fc3e0c2.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t01912b5fe574897130.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t01170eed50edb1e0a7.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t0165b63941f8afebef.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t0128914212fd695301.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"337","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t01730b35a8ce2057fc.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t013c3e5d729fd52b23.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t011837595398d45462.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t01aa43c49069aadf77.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t017e564466f8b6a05a.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t014d28525c663e8072.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t015a54049e49cc6ba4.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t013d2b6e2715edfd8c.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t019aa74805a9eaf8c1.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t01364964dd7167fd07.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t010cbe23a5b3952794.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t015d99773ea207ad05.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t01a86bdb05c440e0d4.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"367","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t01bcc25ba3e927583e.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"402","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t01e0ad294eea539b9c.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t015302241a77a94d31.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t0156d97d087ce94c9a.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t017e21d38da137990a.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t01551ddbdecd6c037c.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t017f5279c9d0fa745a.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t01ede698b938781d82.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t01fabda942bf95438b.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t01bf95a22cf58188f6.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"387","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t017344c32b09b5bf80.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"577","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t01cf0061b96134db58.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"576","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t013085b83522f40f1a.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"331","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t0117e9242b9483eaa7.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"535","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t01ff6b29ddc791fdda.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"522","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t0142b76ff84fa78644.jpg","width":"600"},{"desc":"","height":"338","title":"","url":"https://p0.ssl.img.360kuai.com/t01a589d7e1eae17f96.jpg","width":"600"}]}],"original":0,"pat":"art_src_1,qihu_negative,fts0,sts0","powerby":"hbase","pub_time":1666428621000,"pure":"","rawurl":"http://zm.news.so.com/f9aaef06988f88019949eb47a4747ba8","redirect":0,"rptid":"a21864f0cf94c664","s":"t","src":"什么值得买","tag":[{"clk":"kdigital_1:ddr4","k":"ddr4","u":""},{"clk":"kdigital_1:ddr5","k":"ddr5","u":""},{"clk":"kdigital_1:微星","k":"微星","u":""},{"clk":"kdigital_1:rtx","k":"rtx","u":""}],"title":"打造全家桶炫彩RGB主机,XPG全新水冷风扇和D5内存上机体验
@明谭朱15566088177#   电脑的水冷和风冷到底哪种好 -
#廉玲航2964: 一般风冷就能满足需要了.水冷都是发烧友,喜欢自己瞎捣鼓弄得.

@明谭朱15566088177#   电脑水冷散热真的比风冷散热好吗?
#廉玲航2964: 欢迎点击右上角关注:「数码小评」,更多有趣资讯等着您哦.首先关于这个问题,其它争论了好久,有人说好的风冷不比水冷差,也有人说水冷吊打风冷,其实这个都有...

@明谭朱15566088177#   散热器:水冷还是风冷好? -
#廉玲航2964: 水冷好 通常的风冷散热方案都采用风扇+金属散热片的设计,CPU发散出的热量传输到散热片上,然后通过风扇将散热片的热量吹走.这样的设计要提高散热效率,只有增加散热片体积和增大风扇风量两种方法,太大体积对于机箱有限内部显然...

@明谭朱15566088177#   小白不太懂 水冷和风冷差距求详细说明 -
#廉玲航2964: 这么说吧,就像是空调和电风扇的差距.不是一个档次的东西,水冷的机箱一般都是高端机箱才会采用的,属于液态降温.不过水冷的问题是时间久了容易漏液,而风扇的问题是时间久了噪音更大.总的来说,对于一般的七八千块以下的电脑主机而言,风冷都是可以压得住.

@明谭朱15566088177#   机箱水冷好还是风冷好
#廉玲航2964: 那要看你是不是准备配水冷的,机箱只不过为水冷留了个放置水管的位置,没有也不要紧,可以换一条得孔的PCI挡板.

@明谭朱15566088177#   电脑散热器水冷的好还是风冷的好?
#廉玲航2964: 当然是水冷,逼格高效果好静音强,高端主机一般都用水冷.

@明谭朱15566088177#   电脑水冷好还是风冷好?
#廉玲航2964: 肯定是水冷的好

@明谭朱15566088177#   计算机主机水冷有什么优缺点,尽量详细,最好和风冷对比一下~~~
#廉玲航2964: 水冷相对于风冷来说最大的有点就是静音,即没有噪音 但水冷系统相对比较复杂,安装也是如此 风冷属于比较传统的散热方式,安装方便,价格也相对低廉.但品质较差的风扇散热器散热效果差不说,噪音也大,这是风冷的主要缺点 总体来说,大多数用户如果没有特殊要求,风冷够用了;水冷这种非常规散热方式适用于有一定经济基础、喜欢研究折腾的发烧友 希望我的回答对你有帮助!

@明谭朱15566088177#   台式电脑风冷散热器好还是水冷散热器好 -
#廉玲航2964: 风冷对机箱散热要求比较高,热量散到机箱内不能迅速排出的话就会在机箱内部循环累积.优点是安装简单,维护成本低.记得定时除尘,否则再高端的风冷也是会变低效率的!水冷是用散热排直接把热量吹到机箱外,热量不会在机箱内循环和累积.优点是比较安静,温度可以控制的比较低.缺点就是安装会比较麻烦(喜欢折腾电脑的当我没说),水冷液一般需要每年定时更换,如果是PVC水管也要同时一起更换.

@明谭朱15566088177#   电脑的散热用水冷好还是风冷? -
#廉玲航2964: 这个不能单纯的来这样比较.水冷的效果理论上是一定比风冷好,但是也取决于你水冷头的做工,水泵的扬程流量,散热排的材质和大小.现在的风冷也做得很好,多热管大面积散热排高转数风扇...


相关视频:
  • 机械大师C+MAX 风冷和水冷效果对比!4090索泰AMP!4080火神!
  • CPU散热器-水冷 风冷该怎么选择?#电脑 #组装电脑 #电脑知识
  • 利民SS135风冷与入门水冷散热PK#电脑 #电脑装机 #机箱散热
  • 风冷比水冷散热器更好吗?
  • 大霜塔vs利民FS140vs堡垒240等,到底双塔风冷240水冷该选谁?
  • “最强”水冷横向对比风冷,现在差距有多大了
  • CPU 水冷散热器真的比风冷好吗?分体水冷?温度高了会爆?
  • 摩托车水冷虽好也有缺点,风冷也有优点。机车水冷风冷优缺点介绍
  • 风冷VS一体水冷 谁更适合R7 3700X?利民AS120对比安耐美虹彩晶凌
  • 【风冷炮】最强风冷VS一体式水冷,风冷的荣誉由我守护